GCAR501(c)(7) · MEDIUMNAICS 713910EIN 11-0787820

Garden City Golf Club

Garden City, NY · founded 1941
13 filings on recordFY 20112023medium confidence
FY23 Total Revenue
$7.66M
▲ 14.2% YoY
FY23 Total Expenses
$6.97M
▲ 4.2% YoY
Operating Margin
9.0%
revenue minus expenses ÷ revenue
Employees
92
headcount as reported on filing

The Five-Year Picture

FY2019 — FY2023 · as filed
Revenue
$7.7M
▲ 12.9% / 5y
6.86.37.06.77.7
Expenses
$7.0M
▲ 16.6% / 5y
6.05.96.46.77.0
Total Assets
$9.9M
▲ 30.9% / 5y
7.58.38.79.19.9
Total Liabilities
$738K
▲ 88.1% / 5y
392376323667738

Year-on-year detail

from IRS Form 990
LineFY19FY20FY21FY22FY23Δ total
Revenue$6.8M$6.3M$7.0M$6.7M$7.7M+12.9%
Expenses$6.0M$5.9M$6.4M$6.7M$7.0M+16.6%
Net surplus$811K$391K$506K$15K$691K-14.8%
Total assets$7.5M$8.3M$8.7M$9.1M$9.9M+30.9%
Total liabilities$392K$376K$323K$667K$738K+88.1%
Net assets$7.1M$7.9M$8.4M$8.5M$9.1M+27.7%

Officer & staff compensation

FY23 · from IRS Form 990
Officer · EmployeeReportableOther
MICHAEL A MCALEAVEY
Golf Course Superintendent· 40h/wk
$302,665$53,930
DANIEL REKUS
General Manager· 40h/wk
$282,917$41,316
NICHOLAS AMATO
Controller· 40h/wk
$158,500$34,589
PAUL SCHRADER
Executive Chef· 40h/wk
$157,273$34,448
ROBERT C RITTBERGER
Head Golf Professional· 40h/wk
$147,485$40,642
HENRY MELARA
Assistant General Manager· 40h/wk
$136,282$33,337
EVAN BLACKWOOD
ASST. GREENS SUPERINTENDENT· 40h/wk
$116,321$13,584

+ 12 unpaid officers/directors as reported (ALEXANDER F DEMATTEIS, B CHARLES MANNING, DONALD J MCDONOUGH III, +9 more)

Top contractors

FY23 · vendors paid $100k+ as reported

No contractors reported.

Revenue by activity

FY23 · dues, greens fees, dining, and other sources
Line itemAmount
MEMBERSHIP FEES$4,626,160
INITIATION FEES$1,112,275

GFounded in 1941, Garden City Golf Club reported $7.66M of revenue for FY23, at an operating margin of 9.0%. Revenue moved up 14.2% against the prior posted return. Every figure on this page is drawn from the club’s Form 990 as filed; a dash marks a value the filing did not report.

Source documents
Form 990, FY2023 · period ending Sun Dec 31 2023 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Form 990, FY2022 · period ending Sat Dec 31 2022 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Form 990, FY2021 · period ending Fri Dec 31 2021 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
+ 10 more · via ProPublica
BLTS $29.2M ▲4.1
STLC $18.4M ▲8.1
ESSX $15.3M ▲11.2
TRDN $17.7M ▼1.4
MRON $17.0M ▲5.2
live feed
The Quarterly · delivered free

Read the filings
before the board does.

Every new 990, every shift in the compensation bands, every notable year-over-year swing — compiled into one briefing each edition, for the people who actually run these clubs.

4,200+
GMs · controllers · board members
4×
a year · never more
Subscribe
Quarterly only · no spam · unsubscribe in one click

“I read it before our finance committee meets.”
— GM, top-50 club

Privacy PolicyDisclaimerMethodology© 2026 Country Club Intel
The Quarterly · free
The filings, the comp, the movers — four times a year.
Quarterly only · no spam · unsubscribe in one click